• 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 24th, 2025

help-circle

  • Shouldn’t we trust the process and support the market in figuring it out?

    No because that is how neoliberalism just hollows the industries that all other industries depend on. There’s a reason China builds more HSR and subway lines, ships, and solar panels than the rest of the world combined.

    We have market economies because central planning has shown its limits.

    Markets are a specific tool that is useful in some areas and destructive in others. For example, if China didn’t mandate bauxite mining operations extract gallium, the mines would never build the required infrastructure because it takes ages to pay off the capital investment required to do so, if it does at all, and China would have the same capacity to manufacture LEDs and derived products as the rest of the world, almost none.

    Same with batteries. There’s a dozen companies, but the 5 year plans and ability to intervene if the capitalists try to not compete or hollow out their industry in the name of profit ensures those companies have the quantity and price of input those companies need to reduce the price of batteries as low as possible.

    among all the engineers, who selects the competent ones?

    Presumably people who are able to evaluate their performance. Unlike in capitalism where those engineers are selected by the people with the most money.



  • well planned

    They manufacture more than anyone else in the world because of how effective their planning has been.

    “technologically superior”

    They have factories they don’t even bother to turn the lights on due to how automated it is. You’re using stereotypes that haven’t had any basis in reality for over a decade.

    “they don’t pay their workers hardly anything

    Eh, kinda, wages are still quite low, but for the last 20 years, labor-intensive work that can’t be automated has been leaving China for countries whose wages haven’t increased.

    and regularly utilize slave labour at a large scale

    China doesn’t use slave labor lmao.

    If it was only an issue of low wages and high population, India would be the biggest manufacturer in the world.